Interesting words from BP
Joe Sheehan of Baseball Prospectus took a look at the Blue earlier this week as part of his peek into lessons learned from ST, and had some interesting observations on how the Blue might dole out playing time between the vets and kids. Obviously things will play out over the course of the season, but at least according to Sheehan, early indications will be pleasing to many fans:
"The Dodgers might be all right. Without fanfare, without declarations, and with a minimum of drama, Joe Torre seems to be coming around to what outsiders have been saying all winter: Juan Pierre is his fourth outfielder. As March has progressed, as the three players make it very clear in which order they should receive playing time, Torre has said as little as possible about the situation, but increasingly doled out starts to Andre Ethier and Matt Kemp at Pierre’s expense.
The biggest fear in the Dodgers’ hiring of Torre is that the preference for experience he showed in the latter half of his Yankees tenure would carry over, and lead him to play Pierre over better players. It doesn’t appear that is going to happen, and while the situation will have to be managed, better to manage a personnel situation and play the right guys than solve the happiness issue by making the baseball team worse.
The parallels between Juan Pierre and Luis Gonzalez are interesting. Gonzalez had a longstanding reputation as one of the good guys in the game, and I’ve no doubt that, outside of a baseball uniform, he earns that. In Arizona in 2006 and in Los Angeles in 2007, however, Gonzalez was a divisive presence the moment his playing time was reduced. Pierre, also by acclamation one of the game’s better people, now finds himself in the same spot, and by all accounts, is grousing a bit about it.
To me, it goes to the whole notion of how players get labels, and how worthless those labels are in practice. Regardless, Torre has to put the best team on the field, and he appears prepared to do that. This decision bodes well for a future one on Andy LaRoche, who is a much better player than the current version of Nomar Garciaparra, and should similarly get the playing time ahead of the veteran once his thumb heals."
BK

OK, here we go again at the end of Mr. Sheehan's article, we are shown again how everything will be rosy for the kid who has never showed anything at the major league level. Comparing the Juan Pierre/Andre Ethier or Matt Kemp scenario with Nomar/Andy is comparing apples to oranges. Would someone PLEASE show me why Andy is such a great escape from Nomar, other than he is younger? You can't judge by potential alone!!! Also, it looks like Andy gets hurt as much as Nomar. I guess I just miss the point. Because so many want youth on the team, they are willing to push aside proven talent. CRAZY.
Package
Posted by: Package | March 29, 2008 at 01:35 PM
For Civil Rights Day I just wanted to post my all-time African-American Dodger Team
Maury Wills SS
Junior Gilliam 3B
Willie Davis CF
Jackie Robinson 2B
Tommy Davis LF
John Roseboro C
Lou Johnson LF
James Loney 1B
Don Newcombe P
Thanks y'all. Peace out. Support RBI program in the Hood!
Posted by: Crenhshaw Mark | March 29, 2008 at 02:58 PM
I hope Pierre doesn't become a malecontent. He could be such a useful late inning option on the basepaths
Posted by: K T USN (almost retired) | March 29, 2008 at 04:12 PM
Crenshaw,
Since you included two leftfielders, would you consider Reggie Smith in RF as a suitable replacement for Lou Johnson?
Posted by: Brooklyn Dodger | March 29, 2008 at 06:42 PM
Crenshaw Mark,
I always thought Roy Campenella was a pretty good catcher!
Posted by: TimDodger | March 30, 2008 at 07:45 AM